Algorithmic Power: The Role of Big Tech in the Instrumentalization of Law and Its Conflict with Political Authority


Birdal C.

The 32nd World Congress of the International Association Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, İstanbul, Türkiye, 28 Haziran - 03 Temmuz 2026, (Özet Bildiri)

  • Yayın Türü: Bildiri / Özet Bildiri
  • Basıldığı Şehir: İstanbul
  • Basıldığı Ülke: Türkiye
  • İstanbul Üniversitesi Adresli: Evet

Özet

In the contemporary technological era, the global landscape is witnessing a nascent conceptualization of power and a distinctive shift in political conflict. This nascent conceptualization brings a new concept called algorithmic power. Algorithmic power can be defined as the capacity of automated systems driven by algorithms and data which shape the society and human behaviour. Algorithmic power is an invisible, subtle and pervasive form of power which uses data and choice architecture as control mechanisms. This form of power controls the mind and desire by the help of collecting user data, manipulates individuals by tracking their behaviour through data surveillance. Individuals unconsciously make choices that they perceive as their own. The rapid rise of algorithmic power in recent years has been driven by the dominance of tech giants (Big Tech) that have established monopolies in the market. This rise has influenced politics, leading to the instrumentalization of the law.

How Big Tech instrumentalizes the law is a matter that needs to be considered for the future of the law. Unlike traditional private law legal entities, Big Tech now acts as a de facto legislator, establishing its own normative order through code and platform governance. Big Tech creates contracts with users by unilaterally setting rules through terms of service that include provisions such as intellectual property rights, how data will be processed, which court or arbitration will have jurisdiction in the event of a dispute, and disclaimers of liability. In addition, these companies set community guidelines for their users which can sometimes lead to the suppression of users' freedom of expression and the restriction of their right to access information.

The conflict between political authority and Big Tech will be examined in this study from political, economic, and social perspectives. From a political standpoint, the most controversial aspect of this conflict is how these companies influence voters' decision-making processes, even in democratic governments. Influencing political decision-making processes determines the government of the country in question by directing voter behaviour. It's as if algorithmic power gains the ability to determine the political course of events. The Cambridge Analytica data scandal, which jeopardized the 2016 election process and involved Mark Zuckerberg's testimony, is one of the most significant examples of this.

Big Tech controls the digital infrastructure through which the state performs its core functions. This leads to the political authority becoming dependent on corporations. This dependency relationship is essentially symbiotic. The apparent conflict between political authority and corporations is actually circumvented by the role and power of corporations in international competition. Big Tech is known to spend enormous sums of money on lobbying activities. The revolving door – the transfer of high-ranking bureaucrats in public institutions to technology companies and the transfer of company executives to the state as consultants – ensures that public economic policies align with the vision of these companies, allowing Big Tech to influence economic policy.

Big tech, in addition to its political and economic impacts, also affects society. The digital realm is now replacing the public sphere, whose boundaries were drawn by political authority, and technology companies are shaping the ground of public debate. The state's power of surveillance has passed into the hands of private companies, and platforms have gained the power to discipline society through consumption. The exclusion of certain individuals and groups from platforms, the suppression of certain news, and the phenomenon of information cocoons—where individuals are surrounded by content that reinforces their existing beliefs based on digital algorithms—create cognitive isolation and deepen social polarization.

As algorithmic power expands its reach from mundane daily routines to macro-level governance—traversing the boundaries between the public and private spheres—it effectively constricts the traditional domain of political power. This encroachment creates a structural conflict between technological sovereignty and state authority, manifesting as either systemic tension or strategic consensus. The trajectory of this conflict is poised to redefine the future of legal systems. This study examines, through contemporary case studies, whether law is being instrumentalized within the escalating friction between algorithmic power and political authority.

Keywords: Algorithmic power, Big Tech, Conflict Theory, Instrumentalization of Law, Political Authority.