The Moderator Role of Spouses' Centrality Profiles in the Effects of Conflicts Between Work and Family in Dual-Earner Families


Res. Asst. PhD Ferhat AYYILDIZ

Thesis Type: Doctorate

Institution Of The Thesis: Istanbul University, Faculty of Literature, Department of Psychology, Turkey

Thesis Supervisor: İlknur Özalp Türetgen

Approval Date: 2024

Thesis Language: Turkish

Supported Program: Teaching Staff Training Program

Abstract:

Conflicts between work and family domains have been a popular topic of investigation in the literature, and research has revealed the individual and organizational outcomes of these conflicts. However, there hasn't been enough focus on the variables that moderate these effects, and most studies have been individual-centered in examining conflict processes. To overcome these limitations, the aim of the current study is to examine the moderating roles of the centrality profile of the individual, their spouse, and the couple together on the effects of conflicts in dual-earner families on job satisfaction, job performance, marital satisfaction, family performance, and psychological strain. The study was conducted with a voluntary participant group of 340 dual-earner families (340 women, 340 men). Initially, based on the centrality individuals attribute to work and family domains, cluster analysis revealed that individuals could be categorized into four different profiles: "family-centric", "work-centric", "dual-centric", and "other-centric". At the couple level, considering the centrality attributed to work and family by both the individual and their spouse, cluster analysis identified seven clusters reflecting different couple centrality profiles. The findings regarding the moderating effect of the individual’s, spouse's, and couple’s centrality profiles showed that the impact of centrality profiles varies not only according to the direction of the conflict but also according to the outcome variable examined. Individuals experiencing the least negative effects of work-family conflict in the work domain were found to be "work-centric", while those experiencing the most negative effects were "other-centric". Conversely, in the family domain, the opposite was observed: "other-centric" individuals were the least affected, and "work-centric" individuals were the most affected by both work-family and family-work conflicts. Regarding the spouse's centrality profile, as work-family conflict increased, marital satisfaction decreased the most, and psychological strain increased the most among individuals whose spouse was "work-centric". Additionally, as family-work conflict increased, marital satisfaction decreased the most, and family performance declined the most among individuals whose spouse was "work-centric". Finally, the findings on the moderating effect of the couple’s centrality profile also demonstrated that a profile at the couple level does not solely play a mitigating or exacerbating role; rather, individuals in different couple profiles may become more advantageous or disadvantageous compared to others in the face of conflict, depending on the outcome variable. Women in couples in which “both spouses are family-centric" were found to be more negatively affected by family-work conflict in terms of job satisfaction and family performance, but they experienced weaker effects of family-work conflict on psychological strain. Additionally, it was observed that women and men in the same couple profile could be negatively affected by different types of conflicts. In the couple profile where “the woman is other-centric and the man is dual-centric", women's family performance was more strongly impacted by work-family conflict, while men's family performance was more strongly impacted by family-work conflict compared to their counterparts in other couple profiles. When the results are evaluated together, it is understood that the outcomes of conflict in individuals with different centrality profiles, both at the individual and couple levels, may vary depending on factors such as the source of the conflict, the domain of the outcomes being examined, and the type of outcome variable. The findings have been discussed in light of the literature, with potential explanations provided, organizational implications assessed, and suggestions for future research offered.