Critical and creative thinking as key components of strategic thinking in strategic communication, leadership and innovative management: A road map based on a case of an Erasmus+ funded online educational program


ÖZKOYUNCU F.

EUPRERA 2017 Annual Congress, Londra, United Kingdom, 12 - 14 October 2017, pp.14, (Full Text)

  • Publication Type: Conference Paper / Full Text
  • City: Londra
  • Country: United Kingdom
  • Page Numbers: pp.14
  • Istanbul University Affiliated: Yes

Abstract

Strategic thinking employs, by definition, an experiment that helps generate “critical thoughts” to test options that it offers, and forms a particular analysis by putting critical questions, which means that it covers critical thinking ability that all strategic decision makers should possess. Critical thinking is defined as the intellectually disciplined process of actively conceptualizing, analysing, applying, synthesizing, or evaluating information collected from experience, observation, reasoning, reflection, or communication.  It comprises of processes such as making strategies into practice with no pressure from others, and avoiding a strategic deviation by using a constant critical approach. It includes processes of thinking on concrete and abstract topics to form clear and explicit judgments that suit to reason and scientific evidence. On that sense it complements creative thinking.

 

Also, an executive competent to think strategically needs abilities to perceive and categorise distinctness among objects or situations to describe environmental change. In the process of decision making or strategy formulation, such an executive should be able to analyse, from a conceptual perspective, relations among different parts of organizational system, its background and body, in order to take actions considering the fact that a change in some parts of the organizational system would affect others.  From this perspective, strategic and critical thinking are constantly interacting with each other. Previous research revealed that the primary skill to be built in courses of strategic management is “ability of critical thinking in strategic topics”, and a good strategic leader should do exercises of critical thinking.

 

In other respects, creative thinking is a process of identifying the difficulty; searching for solutions, making guesses, or formulating hypotheses and test them in order to identify gaps in knowledge, and fill them. It is about inventing ideas or developing things, while critical thinking is a process of judging the quality of something. Ideas that creative thinking produces have little value if not backed up by critical thinking. It includes discovering ideas and new relations between ideas. It consists of a combination of 3 key elements: “Internal motivation” (inner addiction that pushes one to solve problems), “cognitive abilities” (those affecting individuals’ approach to problems in terms of flexibility and imagination) and “personal expertise” (technical, methodologic and intellectual knowledge). Strategic thinking method, as a combination of systemic thought, creative thinking and large-mindedness, is to find solutions to strategic problems, and is based on associating, integrating, and imagining, thereby “creative thinking ability”. The ability to generate creative ideas has a determining role in such actions as strategic planning. Strategic thinking within an organization involves “making strategic analysis”, “developing a strategic point of view”, “identifying strategic needs” and “planning possibilities and operations” that may form the steps of strategic communication. So, strategic creativity is the key component of strategic thinking.     

 

In this respect our paper deals with the concepts of creative and critical thinking to be able to effectively place them in the curriculum of education of strategic communication and public relations which require strategic thinking. The research regarding the study is twofold. First, we analyse the data we collected from a previous quantitative research in the preparation phase of the EU-funded online education program, E-PROFMAN, intended for strategic communication, leadership and innovative management. This data is based on the results of the questionnaires filled by 286 CEOs; public relations practitioners, teaching staff, or students in Turkey. The questionnaires included questions designed to reveal importance that respondents attach to critical thinking, creative thinking, strategic and systemic thinking as well as skills public relations practitioners need to have to be able to think critically and creatively. Accordingly in this first phase of the research, we deal with critical and creative thinking as an intellectual input: We try to look into the issue of what kind of intellectual input communicators need to have to be able to gain the skills of critical and creative thinking.

 

Second phase of the research consists of in-depth interviews with a group in the same target group, which will be 15 to 20 people including public relations practitioners, teaching staff, and students who took courses in e-PROFMAN program. This provides us with some insights about the way public relations education should be updated since we will have the opportunity to evaluate critical and creative thinking as an intellectual output and to see whether it is achieved. In a nutshell, we will have some crucial hints that will serve to reveal how to embed critical and creative thinking, strategic thinking and problem solving in today’s public relations education to create the ideal road map to follow.