Smart Governance through Digital Participation: Institutional Pathways in Decidim Barcelona and Decide Madrid
SCA'26: Smart Cities & Applications 🏙️ 11th International Conference · Karabük, Türkiye · November 10–12, 2026, 10 - 12 Kasım 2026, cilt.10, ss.1-8, (Tam Metin Bildiri)
- Yayın Türü: Bildiri / Tam Metin Bildiri
- Cilt numarası: 10
- Sayfa Sayıları: ss.1-8
- İstanbul Üniversitesi Adresli: Evet
Özet
Abstract. Digital
participation platforms represent a cornerstone of democratic innovation in
modern municipal governance. However, the presence of civic tech artifacts does
not inherently illuminate how citizen inputs translate into authoritative
decision-making. While two platforms may share common open-source codebases and
technopolitical origins, they often diverge substantially in the institutional
pathways they establish between citizens and local authorities. This paper compares
Decidim Barcelona and Decide Madrid, two paradigmatic benchmarks of
contemporary Spanish municipalism. Drawing on a Most Similar Systems Design
(MSSD) and qualitative analysis of platform architectures, municipal
ordinances, and institutional documentation (2015–2024), this study compares
both platforms across three core dimensions: initiation, translation, and
continuity. The findings demonstrate that Decidim Barcelona embeds input within
institutionally framed, deliberative processes, whereas Decide Madrid offers a
citizen-initiated pathway in which proposals must pass procedural thresholds to
advance. The paper uses “institutional distance” as an analytical lens for
examining the procedural pathway between participation and public authority.
Its findings concern formal platform and institutional architecture, not
measured participation rates or demonstrated policy effects. The comparison
thus points to mechanisms by which platforms shape opportunities for influence,
while noting that their operation and effects require further study using
participant, administrative, and outcome data.