Liquid Protocols: The Infrastructural Politics of Liquidity in Automated Trading between NASDAQ Copenhagen and Borsa Istanbul
SASE 2026 Annual Meeting, Bordeaux, Fransa, 1 - 04 Temmuz 2026, ss.2745-2747, (Özet Bildiri)
- Yayın Türü: Bildiri / Özet Bildiri
- Basıldığı Şehir: Bordeaux
- Basıldığı Ülke: Fransa
- Sayfa Sayıları: ss.2745-2747
- İstanbul Üniversitesi Adresli: Evet
Özet
Building on MacKenzie’s (2021) notion of material political economy and Callon’s (2021) theory of marketization, the research contends that liquidity is performed through calculative and institutional arrangements that define what counts as a tradable and stable market. In this sense, liquidity cannot be reduced to quantitative indicators such as depth, turnover, or bid-ask spread. Instead, it is an infrastructural condition maintained through continuous work at the intersection of code, policy, and organizational habitus. This approach reframes market efficiency not as a statistical property but as an outcome of sociotechnical coordination. The comparative framework draws inspiration from two recent conceptual developments: Caliskan et. al.’s (2024) “stacked economization” and Hansen’s (2025) “stack inversion”. Both conceptual lenses invite an infrastructural reading of market organization. Stack economization treats markets as layered assemblages in which computational, regulatory, and spatial layers co-constitute economic order. Stack inversion extends this by showing how power and governance migrate downward into technical substrates. Applying these insights to trading protocols, the research argues that the OUCH (order entry) and ITCH (market data dissemination) systems should be read as “protocological infrastructures” that materialize distinct moral economies of liquidity. Hence, these protocols are not passive conduits of information but embedding regulatory logics of fairness, speed, and visibility into their operational syntax.
The empirical analysis focuses on two levels of comparison: (i) the technical architectures of OUCH/ITCH as implemented in CPH and BIST; and (ii) the regulatory frameworks that define permissible forms of liquidity. OUCH, optimized for low-latency order submission, mediates the trader–exchange relationship, while ITCH structures how aggregated market data is broadcast to participants. Although both exchanges share NASDAQ’s technical backbone, their implementations diverge sharply in latency configurations, co- location access, and throttling policies. In the Danish context, harmonization with MiFID II and the European Securities and Markets Authority results in near-zero-latency environments and strong obligations toward transparency and fair access. Liquidity is thus enacted as a continuous, tradable flow and it is a resource optimized for algorithmic competition. In contrast, BIST’s version of the same NASDAQ infrastructure includes deliberate latency equalization, throttling mechanisms, and circuit breakers. Here, liquidity appears as a monitored and occasionally suspended flow that is embedded in Türkiye’s prudential regime of financial stability.
These technical differences reflect distinct regulatory imaginaries. In Denmark, market design and regulation are aligned with a European liberal regime of transparency, competition, and market efficiency. The Danish Financial Supervisory Authority’s oversight reinforces a moral economy of openness, competition, and equal access to data. In Türkiye, the Capital Markets Board and BIST emphasize developmental and stability-oriented rationalities. Frequent adjustments to volatility interruption thresholds, message limits, and circuit breakers demonstrate a political-economic configuration where liquidity is a managed and domesticated entity rather than a freely circulating one. These contrasting approaches (continuous liberal liquidity vs. conditional prudential liquidity) reveal how financial infrastructures encode national trajectories of governance and modernization.
The historical legacies of the two exchanges further deepen these contrasts. CPH’s lineage lies in open-outcry trading and early liberal market institutions, cultivating a cultural association between transparency and legitimacy. BIST’s earlier “board system,” in which trades were manually recorded per stock, instilled an archival and supervisory ethos that continues to shape its approach to data visibility and trader accountability. These infrastructural memories (one oriented toward openness and competition while the other leans toward oversight and record-keeping) persist as embedded logics within the digital architectures that replaced them. Thus, even under similar technical standards, historical institutional sediments continue to organize how liquidity is experienced, measured, and morally valued.
By integrating these historical, technical, and regulatory layers, the research advances the notion of “protocological economization”: the process by which liquidity is produced through recursive interactions between code and governance. Queue priority models, timestamp precision, and message throttling are treated, as instruments of regulation, not merely design choices. They distribute visibility, speed, and agency across different categories of actors (human traders, algorithmic agents, regulators, and servers). This infrastructural mediation determines who can act, when, and with what epistemic privilege. As such, liquidity becomes an entity where technical design and political order converge. Hence, far from being a neutral outcome of market forces, liquidity is a contested achievement reflecting specific moral orders of efficiency, fairness, and control. And both cases reveal that liquidity functions as a moral keyword in contemporary capitalism: a symbol of trust in markets’ ability to circulate value smoothly, yet one that is constantly reengineered through infrastructural interventions.
All in all, the research aligns with calls to reconceptualize financial markets as infrastructures of political, moral, and temporal coordination. It bridges the social studies of finance with critical infrastructure studies to show that seemingly technical systems like OUCH and ITCH perform deeply social functions: they structure anticipation, risk, and trust. The analysis of NASDAQ Copenhagen and Borsa Istanbul thus demonstrates how global technical standards coexist with national infrastructural, moral, and political rationalities to produce multiple faces of liquidity. Future research might expand this line of inquiry by tracing how other financial “stacks” (from clearing systems to data centers, for example) encode political choices about what counts as speed, stability, and fairness in an increasingly digitized and automated finance.